The Best Car Rental Companies in the USA (2025)

Looking for America’s best car rental companies? Enterprise leads with a 734 satisfaction score, but surprising alternatives might better suit your needs.

The Best Car Rental Companies in the USA (2025)

I’ve spent a lot of time learning about car rental companies across the USA, and I can tell you that picking the right one can make your trip much easier or more frustrating. Enterprise is usually rated the best by customers, with a score of 734 based on J.D. Power rankings, but there’s more to it than just scores. Whether you want fancy perks or just need to save money, I’ve found out which companies really do what they promise, and which ones you should stay away from.

Top-Performing Rental Companies Leading the Industry

Top Rental Companies in the Industry

Even though the car rental business is very competitive, Enterprise has taken the top spot again with a score of 734 out of 1,000. This is a 5-point increase from last year. Enterprise’s success comes from its balanced approach using helpful digital tools, friendly staff, and clear prices at its 9,000 locations around the world.

National is close behind in second place with 721 points, but it dropped 15 points from last year. These two companies have often taken turns being number one, showing they both offer good service.

Tied for third place are Advantage Rent A Car and Sixt, each with 711 points. Advantage got better by making renting easier and improving its digital tools. Sixt stands out with its modern, European style and high-tech features.

Hertz and Ace Rent A Car follow with 702 and 701 points respectively.

Mid-Tier and Budget-Friendly Options Worth Considering

Even though the biggest and most popular car rental companies usually get the highest customer satisfaction scores, travelers on a budget can still find good options with some mid-priced brands. For example, Thrifty scored 658 points. It offers affordable prices and decent service. Although it’s not the top-rated company, Thrifty has improved its value and fixed some trust issues, especially about automated toll fees.

Budget and Dollar are also good choices if you want to save money and don’t need luxury service. Dollar scored 641 points, which is a bit better than last year, and has 19 types of vehicles, from small economy cars to 12-seaters. Budget has 16 types of vehicles, from basic economy to fancy luxury cars.

If you want clear prices and membership benefits, Payless is available at over 80 locations across the US. It has a program called Payless Perks. However, lately, some customers have noticed slower pickup times, so it’s something to think about.

How to Choose the Right Rental Company for Your Needs

With so many car rental companies all over the USA, choosing the right one depends on what you need for your trip.

First, look for companies that have counters near your arrival airport or in the city to make picking up your car easier.

Next, think about your budget and compare prices on websites like Discover Cars, which shows rates from over 4,000 companies.

It’s also important to pick a company with the right cars. If you’re going on a family trip, look for ones that have SUVs and vans.

If you’re traveling for business, you might want nicer cars from companies like National or Sixt.

If you rent cars often, check if they’ve loyalty programs like Hertz Gold Plus Rewards or National’s Emerald Club, they give you extra perks.

Lastly, read reviews about their customer service and see what their cancellation policies are, especially if your plans might change.

Digital Tools and Loyalty Programs That Enhance Your Experience

Car rental companies now use cool digital tools that make renting a car easier and faster. For example, using their mobile apps or checking in online can save you about eight minutes so you spend around 14 minutes instead of 22 at the counter.

Enterprise is good because it has simple digital options and clear prices, while Sixt has a fancy website and easy-to-use features.

If you rent cars often, loyalty programs can give you extra perks. Hertz Gold Plus Rewards and National’s Emerald Club offer free days, upgrades, and special discounts. But I’ve noticed that even though more people are joining these programs, the benefits aren’t as great as before.

To get the most out of them, pick companies that really appreciate their loyal customers with real rewards and special perks that go beyond just discounts.

Essential Tips for Booking and Maximizing Your Rental Value

If you want to get the best deal when renting a car, it’s smart to book early. Reserving your car in advance usually means lower prices and more choices, especially during busy travel times. Plus, you can get special discounts and pick the kind of car you want without rushing at the last minute.

Booking TipsWhy It Helps
Book EarlySave money and pick your car easily
Compare Different SitesFind the best prices from different companies
Join Rewards ProgramsEarn free days and upgrades for future rentals

When searching on sites like Discover Cars, use filters to find a car that fits your budget and needs. Make sure the price is clear, with no hidden charges, and check the cancellation rules. Also, joining rewards programs from companies like Hertz or National can give you extra perks and discounts to get more value from your rental.

Key Takeaways

I’ve learned a lot about car rental companies so you don’t have to get confused. Whether you like Enterprise’s great service or want cheaper options like Thrifty, you can choose what works best for you. Using online tools and tips, you can find good deals that save you money. Remember, renting a car isn’t just about having wheels, it’s your way to explore and enjoy America’s big roads.

Recommended Travel Resources

These are my trusted travel tools for flights, stays, gear, and more. I use these sites to find deals, stay organized, and travel smarter — and you can too.

  • Google Flights — Track flight deals and explore date options easily.
  • Skyscanner — Flexible search tool to find the cheapest flight routes.
  • KAYAK — Great for alerts, bundles, and comparing airlines.
  • momondo — Finds flight prices other search engines may miss.
  • Hopper — Predicts flight prices and tells you when to book.
  • Booking.com — Hotels and apartments with flexible booking options.
  • Expedia — One-stop shop for flights, hotels, and cars.
  • Airbnb — Unique stays and long-stay options around the globe.
  • Rome2rio — See how to travel anywhere by plane, train, bus, or ferry.
  • Agoda — Great hotel deals, especially in Asia.
  • Hostelworld — Best site for hostels and social stays.
  • TripAdvisor — Reviews and suggestions for hotels, tours, and food.
  • Amazon Travel Gear — Reliable place to shop for luggage, gadgets, and travel essentials.
  • Faveplus Travel Tips — Discover stories, guides, and tips from travelers who’ve been there.

Travel is one of the best gifts I’ve ever given myself, and I want others to experience that same magic. If you’re a travel enthusiast, the faveplus travel site is an all-in-one guide packed with real, actionable steps to help you get out there and explore the world.

Joseph Chanlatte
Travel Blogger
Index